The Quest for Buddha's Legacy/ Kapilavastu ©RohitSinghNegi

The Quest For Buddha's Legacy 

A Rohit Singh Negi Initiative 

The Quest for Ancient Kapilavastu 

The search for the historical site of Kapilavastu in the 19th century was significantly influenced by the accounts of Chinese Buddhist monks Faxian and Xuanzang, who visited the site during their pilgrimages. Their detailed descriptions helped guide archaeologists in identifying potential locations for Kapilavastu.

Tilaurakot, Nepal

Identification: Many scholars and the Nepali Government consider Tilaurakot in the Kapilvastu District of Nepal as the likely site of Ancient Kapilavastu.

Archaeological Evidence: Excavations at Tilaurakot have revealed ancient fortifications, residential structures and artifacts that suggest it was an important settlement during the Buddha's time.

Piprahwa, India

Identification: Another group of researchers and archaeologists support Piprahwa in Uttar Pradesh, India, as the possible location of Kapilavastu.

Archaeological Evidence: Excavations at Piprahwa have uncovered significant Buddhist relics, including a stupa and monasteries. Notably, some scholars argue that the relics found at Piprahwa, which may include remains of the Buddha, indicate its importance as an early Buddhist site.

Historical Context

-Faxian and Xuanzang: The travel accounts of these monks provided critical geographical and cultural information that helped in the identification of potential Kapilavastu sites. They described the location and features of Kapilavastu in relation to other significant Buddhist sites.

Archaeological Findings: 

Both Tilaurakot and Piprahwa contain ruins that date back to the period of the Shakya kingdom, supporting their claims to be the historical Kapilavastu. The evidence includes fortifications, habitation areas, and religious structures that align with descriptions from ancient texts.

Ongoing Debate

The debate over the true location of Kapilavastu remains unresolved, with both Tilaurakot and Piprahwa presenting compelling evidence. Continued archaeological research and discoveries may eventually provide more definitive answers.

Note:-

- The accounts of Faxian and Xuanzang have been pivotal in guiding the search for Kapilavastu.

- Archaeological work at both sites has contributed to the understanding of early Buddhist history and the Shakya kingdom.

Part 2

My Opinion on the Location of Ancient Kapilavastu 

The Ancient city of Kapilavastu, where Prince Siddhartha Gautama (Buddha) spent his early years, has been identified in different places based on historical sources, especially the records of Chinese pilgrims Fa-Hien (Faxian) and Hiuen Tsang (Xuanzang).

According to Fa-Hien (Faxian)– 

Early 5th century CE:

•Fa-Hien visited Kapilavastu around 399–414 CE.

•He mentioned that Kapilavastu was in ruins by his time.

•He described it as being located about 12 yojanas (96 miles or 150 km) from a place called Kushinagar (where Buddha passed away).

•He noted that the city was deserted and only a few monks were living there.

According to Hiuen Tsang (Xuanzang) – around 630–645 CE:

•Hiuen Tsang also found Kapilavastu in ruins.

•He provided more precise distances:

•It was 500 li (about 165 km) from Sravasti, 

and located North of the Rohini River,

•In a fertile plain, near the Himalayan foothills.

•He also described landmarks such as the ruins of the palace, the city wall and stupas commemorating key events in Buddha’s life.

Modern Scholarly Debate and Identification:

There are two main candidates for ancient Kapilavastu:

1. Tilaurakot (Nepal)– most widely accepted by archaeologists:

•Located near Taulihawa, in Kapilvastu District, Nepal.

•Aligns closely with the distances and geographical descriptions given by Hiuen Tsang and Fa-Hien.

Archaeological evidence includes:

•Ancient fortifications,

•Ruins of buildings and roads,

•Artifacts dating to the 6th century BCE.

•Supported by UNESCO and many scholars.

2. Piprahwa (India)– Alternate Theory:

•Located in Siddharthnagar District, Uttar Pradesh, just across the border from Tilaurakot.

•Known for the discovery of an ancient stupa containing relics linked to the Buddha.

•Some Indian scholars argue this was Kapilavastu, and Tilaurakot may have been a satellite town.

Conclusion:

Both Fa-Hien and Hiuen Tsang describe Kapilavastu as being in Northern India/Nepal, near the Himalayan foothills, and already in ruins during their visits. 

Their accounts strongly support the identification of Kapilavastu with Tilaurakot in present-day Nepal, although Piprahwa remains an important site in the broader historical landscape.

Part 3

Evidence points to Tilaurakot as Ancient Kapilavastu

The Nigrodha Grove 

The garden where Prince Siddhartha Gautama (the Buddha) met his father King Śuddhodana after attaining enlightenment is known as:

Nigrodha’s Grove (Nigrodhārāma)

Background:

•After attaining Enlightenment at Bodh Gaya, The Buddha began teaching and traveling.

•When news reached Kapilavastu, King Śuddhodana, his father, requested him to return.

•The Buddha eventually went back to Kapilavastu with a large group of monks.

•Instead of staying in The Royal Palace, he stayed in a grove outside the city—this was Nigrodhārāma, a park or garden belonging to a nobleman named Nigrodha, who was reportedly a Sakya clansman. 

Significance:

•It was at Nigrodha’s Grove that King Śuddhodana came to meet the Buddha.

•The Buddha preached to his Father and other members of the Sakya Clan there.

•Rahula, The Buddha’s son, is said to have joined the Sangha (monastic order) here.

•Many early discourses (suttas) were delivered in this grove.

Location Today:

•Scholars associate Nigrodhārāma with a site near Tilaurakot (Nepal)—the likely location of Ancient Kapilavastu.

•Some ruins and archaeological mounds in the area are believed to be remnants of the grove or nearby monastic structures.

Other Sites:

Other archaeological sites around Tilaurakot, like Niglihawa, Gotihawa and Dhamnihawa, have yielded Asokan Pillars, Stupas and other artifacts that contribute to the understanding of Kapilavastu's location. 

© Rohit Singh Negi

Films Campaigns Initiatives Stakeholders Tourism Culture Destinations Heritage Legacy Hospitality The BicycleMan Initiative